2008 Olympics: Women’s Event Finals
You’ve seen my thoughts on the Men’s Event Finals and to follow up, here’s my take on the Women’s…
Vault: Congratulations to Hong Un Jong who was able to capitalize on the mistake of Cheng Fei, the Gold Medal favorite prior to the finals. A first for North Korea – well done.
Like most everyone else, I was thrilled with Oksana Chusovitina’s silver. Her form seemed somewhat improved to me and her landings were spot on. Doesn’t she normally compete a Tsuk 1.5 for her second vault? That’s what I was expecting anyway and was impressed to see her pull out the double. I hope she continues on to 2012 as she’s been quoted as saying. What an amazing feat that would be!
As anyone who has read my blog will know, I am not at all a fan of an athlete falling and yet winning a medal over someone who did not fall. So I obviously did not agree with places 3 & 4 in the final. Alicia Sacramone hit two clean vaults. Yes, they are not as difficult as Cheng Fei‘s but Cheng fell on her second vault. Sacramone should have had the Bronze. And who didn’t want to Sacramone have success in the final after the rough day she had in the Team Finals? She deserved to medal here and she didn’t.
Bars: Everyone has been going on and on about the bizarre tie-breaker that gave Nastia Liukin the Silver to He Kexin’s Gold. Yes, it was a strange outcome. And I thought Nastia’s routine was better that day. But did anyone else think that Yang Yilin should have taken the Gold? She nailed her routine, had the same start value as Liukin and He (7.7), and she rocked her dismount. What were the deductions for? Regardless, it was a great final.
I also liked seeing Beth Tweddle’s routine. She seemed a tad rushed throughout but she still hit for 4th place. With her ridiculously high start value (7.8!) she almost snuck onto the podium.
Beam: Shawn Johnson finally got a gold here. She hit a near perfect routine and her high A score ultimately put her ahead of Nastia Liukin, who also hit an impeccable set. It was great to see her come out on top here. With three silver medals, I thought Shawn was incredibly gracious in defeat all week but as she said herself:
“Of course, when you’re training your whole life to get to the Olympics, you train for gold,…”
It was great to see her big smile again and to at last have that elusive gold medal.
As for the bronze medal, I wanted to see it go to Russia’s Anna Pavlova. Both she and Cheng Fei had small errors in their routines but I preferred Pavlova’s set overall. They were so close – they had the same difficulty score and their execution scores were only separated by 0.05. Tough call. Who did you think should have had the third spot behind the Americans?
Floor: With Sandra Izbasa taking the Gold, Shawn Johnson the Silver, and Nastia Liukin the Bronze, what an incredible Floor final. I think any one of those 3 could have wound up taking the Gold. Izbasa had the highest difficulty and Liukin the highest execution score. It was fun to watch. And good to see Romania get a gold medal. Doesn’t quite seem like the Olympics if Romania isn’t in the mix, does it?
It was difficult to see Cheng Fei and Anna Pavlova struggle on this event after they both had trouble on Vault but otherwise it was a good final.

And so that concludes my Olympic blogging… for the most part
What did you think of the Women’s Event Finals? Did you agree with the final placements?



August 21st, 2008 at 6:38 pm
I agree that Alicia Sacramone should have earned the bronze on vault, and that Anna Pavlova should have earned the bronze on beam. Anyone else upset that Pavlova was disqualified on vault for a meaningless technicality? I read on another site that she had been saluted by the head judge and told to go, but that the the little red stop sign on the scoreboard wasn’t switched to the green light quickly enough after that. Can anyone confirm this? I believe Pavlova should have earned a medal on vault, also, if not for that error. Overall, it was heartbreaking to watch her miss out again and again on the medals, but I was thrilled with Shawn’s win on beam and Izbasa’s win on floor. I love Izbasa’s floor routine – great music.
August 21st, 2008 at 8:52 pm
I can’t believe you think Liukin could win gold on floor. Her cowboy double front is extremely ugly and disgusting and she twisted her legs all the way through. She’s just not deducted due to her father’s connections and threats to the judges. Lucky she’s got a bronze…
August 22nd, 2008 at 10:51 am
everyone all of a sudden is complaining about gymnasts winning medals with falls, ummmmm…………didn’t paul hamm get a gold medal with a crash onto the judges table?
August 28th, 2008 at 8:22 am
I know t’s old but come on….it’s impossible to score in the 9.2 range with a vault in which both eet are outside of the line(obviously)you put ur hands own, ur butt down and although im sure it’s not in the code, falling onto the judges shoudn’t help you out. I love Paul’s gymnastics, but COME ONE. Athens judging, especially on vault(vault final, Marian DRag and Kyle Shewfelt 3rd and 4th) was a JOKE.It was cool to watch his comeback on tv that night, makes a good storyline for NBC, but really it felt so scripted.
September 1st, 2008 at 11:15 am
My thoughts are
Vault- Sacramone should have gotten bronze
Bars- Nastia 1, He 2, and Yang 3. I wish Beth would have gotten a medal but I feel Yang was better executuion wise.
Beam- I really think with her clean style Nastia should have won, but Shawn had the difficulty and since they both hit she had the edge. Pavlova should have gotten bronze. She deserved it with the routine she performed.
Floor- Izbasa stuck almost all her landings, and had a spectacular routine, Nastia’s artistry should have gotten her another silver, and Shawn should have gotten bronze. Shawn’s choreography was simple. To me it felt like pose, turn, shake, tumble.
September 2nd, 2008 at 5:25 am
My thoughts:
OK with vault, SAcramone play safe and the code doesn’t encourage that, sorry… For the reccord: Cheng Fei did the best amanar of the year anfd one of the best ever, so bronze is OK.
Bars: Yang Yilin 1st! She was sooooo robbed!! At least 3 Tenths ahead the other two. 2nd He Kexin 3rd Nastia (but with that preposterous dismount I’ve rather place Beth here if she had hit)
BB: Unartistic performances should not get the gold.
1. Nastia, 2. PAvlova, 3. Fei/JOhnson
FX: Unartistic performances shouldn’t even medal.
1. Jiang Yuyuan, 2. SAndra Izbasa, 3. NAstia Liukin.
AA: 1. Yang Yilin, 2. NAstia Liukin, 3. Ksenia Semenova
Please, for the next code: Bring back artistry!!!!. Balance beam art is almost already dead, and FX is agonizing…
September 7th, 2008 at 12:07 pm
I thought bars should have been 1. Yilin 2. Kexin 3. Nastia. Sorry, but Nastia’s dismount is horrid and should be getting at least 6 tenths of execution deductions, if not more, for the cowboying, unpointed toes, and crouched landing.
For beam I agreed with 1st and 2nd place (Nastia didn’t connect her wolf-full), but actually I thought Dragoi should have gotten bronze.
September 11th, 2008 at 10:53 pm
So Much DRAMA! Poor, poor Pavs. Poor, poor Alicia. Poor poor Cheng. As i said in my blog, one of my favourite Beijing moments was Cheng Fei congratulating Izbasa after her routine. What a gracious, beautiful display of sportsmanship!
As for artistry. All i can say is thank god they have dropped the difficulty count down to eight elements. But, as Lyssenko on You Tube says, six would be better. Then we might see some art come back to the sport.
October 5th, 2008 at 9:04 pm
The medals on VT were fair; As much as I like her, Alicia did not deserve bronze just because she went clean and Cheng Fei fell. Cheng had a 0.90 advantage before even starting and she did the best Amanar I’ve seen! I actually think she was underscored on her first vault. She completed her 2nd one and fell on her knees which warrants a 0.8 deduction. If we look at her B scores, we’ll see they were in the low to mid-8s which is fair if we consider that she usually scores in the mid-9s.
December 25th, 2008 at 11:06 pm
Hi Everyone!
This is a pretty cool blog and I would love to see even more great posts and insights… I hope that this is alright, but I just started a gymnastics blog a few hours ago and hope that everyone will come check it out and leave comments and suggestions. The URL is:
http://gymizlife.blogspot.com/ (Called We Love Gymnastics!)
Thanks so much
January 4th, 2009 at 11:24 am
i think if cheng wasn’t in the beam fina (which i did NOT agree with at al) deng Linlin woulod have been. her opening pass is amazing and performed with absolute maximum execution. be looking for her in the future on vault to (worl cup she made a vault final w/ 2 vaults)
January 26th, 2009 at 1:13 pm
Vault: Hong un Jong is obvious and correct. I think Sacramone should have received silver for her vaults. Her form is so much cleaner than Oksana Chusovitina’s. Oksana muscles her way through the vaults and while she does make it around, it looks uncomfortable and unclean in the air, although I agree with this blog’s comment that Oksana’s form did look better than the last few World championships. I think Hong un Jong’s vaults tend to look a little forced as well. When Cheng Fei hits, she is the cleanest and best by far, but you can’t medal with such an obvious, big mistake. There are some general rules of sport that should apply even in gymnastics. She can’t be awarded for something that she didn’t do. In basketball, when a player attempts a 3-point shot, they aren’t awarded 3 points for the basket going in, 2 points if it hits the rim, 1 point if it hits the backboard, and 0 points if it misses everything. That may not seem like an appropriate comparison, but I actually think it makes a lot of sense. I think there has to be a line drawn somewhere that says you either make or don’t make the vault and then judge the ones that make it on how well they executed it. If the athlete lands on his/her knees or back or stomach or anything other than his/her feet, then its a miss. Sorry. ooops. 0.0
Bars: I would have placed Kexin, Yiln, Liukin. He Kexin’s release skills are exciting and high-flying and put her in a more unique place than the other athletes. She’s fun to watch, and her form is excellent. She was the best.
Beam: Johnson, Liukin, Pavlova
I think Johnson’s tumbling is powerful and fun to watch, but the execution of her leaps is hard to award as stellar and the best in the world. She also doesn’t do any kind of handstand skills like Liukin and Pavlova both do. Pavlova is my favorite, but she didn’t hit when it counted.
Floor: Johnson, Izbasa, Liukin
I actually think this is Johnson’s best event. Her tumbling form and difficulty are superior to the other athletes, and while her choreography is not sophisticated, it’s good enough and plays to her strengths enough that she should have won this event. Izbasa was good, but I thought she had a few low landings that didn’t impress me, and the choreography was just ok. Liukin is definitely an artist, with beautiful twisting skills; however, I can’t see awarding the best floor exercise routine to an athlete that doesn’t show at least one superior double salto skill. Her double front is just ok. Would love to see her improve her tumbling over the next quadrennium.
January 28th, 2009 at 5:28 am
Please!!!!!!!!!!!!!update your site!!!!!!!!!!!!!
April 11th, 2009 at 11:44 am
So I agree with you about vault I think alicia sacramone deserved that bronze medal absolutly.. I think with the unlimited A score oppertunities the athletes have now they need to raise the cost of a fall (which from what i remember at the 2009 american cup it is now 1 point?) but maybe even higher then that.. so that way if you are going to take the risk and hit you will be richly rewarded but you cant take the risk.. miss and still come on top.. so each athlete will have to weight those odds..
I would have loved to beth tweddle medal on bars.. she came so close, if she would have stuck her dismount I believe she would have had bronze.. amazing difficulty.. and I kind of liked her speed through out the routine… if was fast yet controlled
beam and floor I was happy with =)
June 1st, 2009 at 3:56 pm
I agree with you on vault. Alicia Sacramone deserved to win the bronze medal, and Oksana Chusovitina did really well.
I also loved Beth Tweddle on bars. She is amazing. I beleive that she should have won the bronze medal instead of fourth.
Sandra Izbasa did well on floor.
As did Shawn on beam.
I’m happy with both!
April 2nd, 2010 at 3:00 pm
i aggree too
August 28th, 2010 at 9:03 am
I am sooo pissed that Cheng Fei got both of those bronze medals!
She is a sore loser and doesn’t deserve either of them….she’s just inconsistent!
Alicia I think deserved at least a silver if not gold! Hong Un Jong’s Vault’s were difficult but she landed and stepped out of bounds on both! On bars I think is was f**king biased! Seriously! In the past olympics i u tie you tie! They BOTH get GOLD medals! Also Beth deserved bronze! Woo hoo go Beth! Once again…stupid Cheng fei! Go Anna she was soooo much cleaner! Cheng fei had at least two 3 tenth wobbles and i got a full point off her score! She sucks…the bronze goes 2 Anna! Im good with floor! AA was shawn’s, she deserved this! She is the best gymnast in the world! Also instead of Yang Yilin in 3rd i’d give it 2 Yang Yuyuan! She is awesome!
Vault:
Gold: Hong Un Jong
Silver: Alicia Sacramone
Bronze: Oksana Chusovitna
Bars:
Gold: Nastia Liukin- He Kexin
Silver: Yang Yilin
Bronze: Beth Tweddle!
Beam:
Gold: I <3 Shawn Johnson
Silver: Nastia Liukin
Bronze: Anna Pavlova
Floor:
Gold: Sandra Izbasa
Silver: Shawn Johnson
Bronze: Nastia Liukin
AA:
Gold: Shawn Johnson
Silver: Nastia Liukin
Bronze: Jiang Yuyuan!
October 29th, 2010 at 11:32 am
Cheng Fei deserved deserved a medal simply because her Amanar was beautiful. And her difficulty was really high… But I am so glad chuso got silver, she’s been competing at senior level for longer than most her ‘opponents’ have been born.
Therefore, I reckon Vault should have gone like this:
Gold: Hong Un Juong
Silver: Chuso!
Bronze: Cheng Fei
Exactly how it was.
Bars:
Gold: He Kexin
Silver: Yang Yilin
Bronze: Beth Tweddle
He Kexin deserved that gold because she’s fun and exciting. Unlike Liukin who succeeds at pissing me off with that HORRID landing. he ‘perfect form’ as some people say can eff off. Yang Yilin was awesome and deserved a silver. Beth had that great routine with a ridiculously high difficulty and was shunted. Again. So I gave her bronze
Beam:
Same…
Floor:
Gold: Sandra Izbasa
Silver: Johnson
Bronze: Jiang Yuyuan.
Again, Liukin pisses me off. jiang Yuyuan on the other hand, turned the competition into a performance. Entertaining and fun. Love her floor music.
AA:
Same… but Nastia, again… do you want me to repeat myself?