Gymnastics and Gymnastics Ramblings08 Nov 2006 04:15 pm
3 things I dislike in the world of Gymnastics…
- Tank leotards in competition. They seem unprofessional. Call me old-fashioned but I just don’t like it. I know that some athletes think a sleeveless look will give them longer lines and make them more aesthetically appealing to the audience and judges. But I’m not sure I buy it. If you don’t have the look, you don’t have it and showing the skin on your arms won’t make that big of a difference. A gymnast wears a tank leotard pretty much every single day in practice. Is it too much to ask that when it’s competition time she put away the tank and put on the long-sleeved? It’s like showing up to a formal dance in a sun dress. It just doesn’t look right. And besides…it’s tradition and I’m a sucker for tradition.
- Gym shoes. They are just so unattractive. Wearing them on Vault is one thing. It helps some athletes grip the runway better as they run and prevents slipping on the board. But on the Beam? What is up with that? It completely cuts off the line of the leg and you lose the point of the toe in the leather. I know that some gymnasts like the traction provided by the shoe when working on the Beam and I would not encourage a gymnast to do something unsafe. If an athlete absolutely must wear them in order to feel secure up there, I’m not about to stop them. But seriously…it doesn’t look good. And gymnastics is supposed to look good. At least put on a Beam shoe (the kind with the straps that cross in the front - think Dominique Moceanu circa 1996) rather than a Vault shoe if you need them on Beam.
Exception to #2: Nadia Comaneci. She must have had shoes that were not near as thick as those of today’s variety because you could hardly tell she had them on. See photo above for proof. They took away nothing from the lines of her legs and her overall artistic presentation, which, in 1976, was in a class all it’s own. And I’ll admit that when I was 6 I was totally into the Beam shoes so I could look like Nadia. Who didn’t want to be like Nadia?
- The leg-up full turn. I can’t tell you how many of the female gymnasts performed this move at the World Championships in Denmark last month. The skill obviously gets some decent bonus in this new code of points but it is out of control. I saw probably a total of 50 during the Worlds coverage (counting some athletes multiple times) and only about 2 that were done well. And on floor it’s the leg-up double turn. Again, very few done well. It’s unfortunate because when done correctly (on Floor and Beam), the leg-up turn can be breathtaking. Until then, the madness with this skill has got to stop. I’m thinking about starting a petition to remove it from the code of points until further notice. Who’s with me?




November 13th, 2006 at 2:09 am
I’m with you about the tank leos during competition. They should be saved for workouts. I’ve been in competetive gymnastics for a couple years now, and I can’t tell you how many meets I’ve been to. We’ve always had long sleeve leos, but I remember this one year when our team switched to a tank leo. It was horrific. It wasn’t as hot, which was the goal, but I don’t think that we should have sacrificed our long sleeve leos for our comfort in tank leos. It never could really get us as pumped up for a competition like the long sleeve leos could, because it didn’t really give us the feeling that we were competing.
Tank leos also don’t help to display a gymnast’s ability to compete outside her comfort zone, it shows a sign of weakness. A gymnast should be able to have her routines down solid, and show that she can compete under all foreign circumstances, which include different apparatus, time-change, timed warm-ups, AND a different leo. Tank leos partly ruin the whole point of a competition.
I’m starting a new blog website for gymnastics, and a couple other topics, but gym will be my main focus. So feel free to make comments on my upcoming blogs!
December 6th, 2006 at 7:58 pm
I agree about the leos. I have never seen the shoes!
January 9th, 2007 at 10:46 am
I always figured I was the only old fashioned one! I don’t like tank leotards in competition either.
January 13th, 2007 at 12:43 pm
I have been a competitive gymnast for probably 6 years now. I agree with you all the way about shot-sleeve leos. My gym has had long sleeve leotards every year and we don’t plan to change them. Teams look so unprofessional in tank leos. About the shoes though. I agree that they can look bad but some people just have to wear them . I have suffered from sever’s disease for 3 years now, and the shoes work like a miracle to me. If a gymnast gets the right kind and the right color they can look ok.
March 28th, 2007 at 6:33 am
Tank leos and shoes - you’re totally right. Personally I feel less secure on the beam with shoes on, as I feel my connection with the apparatus is obstructed.
As for the leg-up full turn, you’re right, many more gymnasts are doing it now, but I don’t have a problem with that. I mean, you always used to expect a normal full turn in a routine, so what’s wrong with them doing the same but with leg up. It’s a really difficult move, but if it’s not done well you won’t get the bonus points for it.
July 10th, 2007 at 3:45 pm
About the beam shoes…I’m sorry but when I do front aerial on the beam and my foot slips and I rip on my feet, do you have a problem with me wearing beam shoes? To me it’s the same thing as saying “go on bars without grips because grips look ugly”, yes grips aren’t the prettiest thing in the world, but they have a purpose, and so do beam shoes. Or my friend has really dry skin and her feet split open and without the beam shoes there would be blood all over the beam. I’m sorry but I don’t think you truly understand the need for beam shoes for some people.
July 19th, 2007 at 10:26 am
Tank leotard and gym shoes I really dont like them! It looks unapealing like you said.
November 30th, 2007 at 7:14 pm
[...] wrote about my distaste for tank leos, gym shoes & the leg-up full turn a few months ago. The list has now expanded. [...]
December 14th, 2007 at 6:23 am
In my opinion sleeveless leotards usually look much better than those with sleeves. Long-sleeved leos look so old-fashioned, even somewhat prude.
December 30th, 2007 at 9:15 am
A bit of a joke…or not:
The three teams, who last quad qualified a full team berth to the Olympics, but this time have not, all wore tank leos: Spain, Canada, and DPRK.
June 23rd, 2008 at 12:55 pm
I’m so late to the party but AMEN!!!! all this last weekend I was hating it. It’s been 2 years and I see no improvment